Paula's Donuts (Sheridan Drive) ★ 4.4

CuisineBakery

Price$

HoursDaily 05:00-15:00 (or until sold out)

Phone+1 716 862 4246

Last verified2026-06-04

Book food experiences in Buffalo

Customizable Private Winery Day Tour Niagara Falls, Canada

Private tour8 - 9 hours5.0 from 4 reviewsfrom $398

Private, fully customizable full‑day winery tour through the Niagara Region. Visit up to five wineries, enjoy guided tastings, and soak in stunning countryside views a...

Check dates and book

From New York: Niagara Falls and Washington DC 3-Day Trip

Multi-day trip3 days3.2 from 6 reviewsfrom $404

Visit Niagara Falls, Washington, DC, and Philadelphia on a 3-day tour from New York, with all entry tickets and transportation included.

Check dates and book

From NYC: Guided Niagara Falls Full-Day Trip

Day trip23 hours4.5 from 573 reviewsfrom $159

Experience the stunning beauty of Niagara Falls on a day trip from New York City that lets you enjoy and visit iconic sites like the American Falls, Goat Island, Horse...

Check dates and book

See all 40 bookable experiences in Buffalo

Location

Address: 2319 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150, Buffalo

Google Maps → Apple Maps → Waze →

More bakeries in Buffalo

Parkside Candy ★ 4.2

Bakery$Mon-Sat 11:00-18:00; Sun 12:00-18:00Walk-in onlySponge candy, old-fashioned candy, soda fountain

Parkside Candy on Main Street at Winspear is a 1927 candy temple, with a walnut soda fountain, oval Adam-period interior and Buffalo's signature sponge candy.

Worth the queue: Sponge candy

3208 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14214 →

Watson's Chocolates (Elmwood) ★ 4.1

Bakery$Mon-Sat 10:00-18:00, Sun closedWalk-in onlySponge candy and chocolates

Watson's Chocolates on Elmwood Avenue is the Buffalo city shop of the Western New York sponge-candy maker hand-crafting confections since 1946.

Worth the queue: Sponge candy

738 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222 →

Fowler's Chocolates ★ 4.3

Bakery$Mon-Sat 10:00-20:00, Sun 10:00-19:00Walk-in onlySponge candy, chocolates

Fowler's Chocolates on Niagara Falls Boulevard is the original maker of Buffalo sponge candy, in business since 1910 and a city signature confection.

Worth the queue: Original sponge candy

2468 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda, NY 14150 →

Caramici's Italian Bakery ★ 4.0

Bakery$Wed-Fri 12:00-18:00, Sat 09:30-13:30Walk-in onlyItalian cookies, biscotti, pastries

Caramici's Italian Bakery on Elmwood Avenue serves Buffalo's Italian-American cookie tray with pignoli, biscotti and seasonal Sicilian sweets to order.

Worth the queue: Pignoli cookies

3200 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217 →

BreadHive Bakery and Cafe ★ 4.6

Bakery$Mon-Fri 07:30-15:00, Sat-Sun 08:00-15:00Walk-in onlyWorker-owned bakery, sourdough breads, bagels

BreadHive on Connecticut Street is Buffalo's worker-owned cooperative bakery, with sourdough breads, hand-rolled bagels and a counter cafe in the West Side.

Worth the queue: Sourdough bagel

402 Connecticut St, Buffalo, NY 14213 →

Five Points Bakery and Toast Cafe ★ 4.8

Bakery$Daily 08:00-15:00Walk-in onlyWhole-grain breads from local-mill wheat

Five Points Bakery on Brayton Street mills its own wheat from Western New York farms and bakes whole-grain sourdoughs at a West Side toast-cafe counter.

Worth the queue: Whole-grain sourdough

44 Brayton St, Buffalo, NY 14213 →

See every bakeries pick in Buffalo →