Watson's Chocolates (Elmwood) ★ 4.1
Watson's Chocolates on Elmwood Avenue is the Buffalo city shop of the Western New York sponge-candy maker hand-crafting confections since 1946.
Worth the queue: Sponge candy
Parkside Candy is a bakery in Buffalo.
Editorially verified June 4, 2026 by Lewis Vaughan, TableJourney editor. Source.
Address: 3208 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14214
Watson's Chocolates on Elmwood Avenue is the Buffalo city shop of the Western New York sponge-candy maker hand-crafting confections since 1946.
Worth the queue: Sponge candy
Fowler's Chocolates on Niagara Falls Boulevard is the original maker of Buffalo sponge candy, in business since 1910 and a city signature confection.
Worth the queue: Original sponge candy
Caramici's Italian Bakery on Elmwood Avenue serves Buffalo's Italian-American cookie tray with pignoli, biscotti and seasonal Sicilian sweets to order.
Worth the queue: Pignoli cookies
BreadHive on Connecticut Street is Buffalo's worker-owned cooperative bakery, with sourdough breads, hand-rolled bagels and a counter cafe in the West Side.
Worth the queue: Sourdough bagel
Five Points Bakery on Brayton Street mills its own wheat from Western New York farms and bakes whole-grain sourdoughs at a West Side toast-cafe counter.
Worth the queue: Whole-grain sourdough
Butter Block on Rhode Island Street in the Five Points neighborhood moved from market pop-up to brick-and-mortar in 2019, with French laminated pastries.
Worth the queue: Almond croissant