Al Forno ★ 4.9Italian$$$$ Order A grilled pizza Margherita and the baked penne with tomato cream sauce.Al Forno on South Water Street invented grilled pizza in 1980 under Johanne Killeen and the late George Germon. Wood-fire kitchen, baked pasta. DetailsReserveDirections
Bacaro ★ 4.4Italian$$$ Order A round of cicchetti at the downstairs bar with a glass of Lugana, then a pasta upstairs.Bacaro on South Water Street has a Venetian-style enoteca downstairs and a full Italian dining room upstairs. Cicchetti, salumeria plates, Italian wines. DetailsReserveDirections
Sarto ★ 4.4Italian$$$ Order A regional pasta off the rotating section, with a pour from the small-producer red list.Sarto returned to its downtown Dorrance Street room in 2024. Regional Italian with a 2024 Wine Spectator Award of Excellence list; weekend live jazz. DetailsDirections