2 pizzeria rooms in Squirrel Hill, editor-picked by TableJourney. All of Squirrel Hill's food · All pizzeria in Pittsburgh.
Mineo's Pizza House ★ 4.6
2128 Murray Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15217
Mineo's Pizza House on Murray Avenue in Squirrel Hill has run a Pittsburgh-style square pizza since 1958. Tangy sauce, crispy crust and a long local loyalty.
Tip: A long-running rivalry with nearby Aiello's; locals pick a side. Counter and dining room both.
Aiello's Pizza ★ 4.4
2112 Murray Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15217
Aiello's Pizza on Murray Avenue in Squirrel Hill runs a thin, crispy-crust pie in Pittsburgh. The other half of Murray Avenue's long-running pizza rivalry.
Tip: Sits a few doors from Mineo's; locals argue which is better. Quick counter service.