What to order at The Old Fashioned

Signature drink
Brandy Old Fashioned sweet, the city's standard
TypeWisconsin tavern
HoursMon-Sun 10:30-22:00
Signature drinkBrandy Old Fashioned sweet, the city's standard

Food program: Wisconsin supper club menu, fish fry, cheese curds

Location

Address: 23 N Pinckney St, Madison, WI 53703

More bars in Madison

The Coopers Tavern ★ 4.6

GastropubMon-Thu 11:00-22:00, Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00, Sun 10:00-22:00

The Coopers Tavern on West Mifflin off Capitol Square is the city's craft-beer-and-Wisconsin-pub flagship with a fish fry, sausages and serious tap list.

Signature drink: Wisconsin craft beer with a fish fry

Food: Gastropub menu, mussels, sausages, fish fry

Mickey's Tavern ★ 4.5

East side neighborhood barMon-Sun 11:00-02:00

Mickey's Tavern on Williamson Street, the east-side music and pinball bar, is a Marquette neighborhood institution with a strong burger menu and late kitchen.

Signature drink: Wisconsin tap beer and a cheap shot

Food: Burgers, sandwiches, kitchen until late

Maduro Cigar Bar ★ 4.4

Cocktail lounge and cigar barSun-Thu 16:00-01:00, Fri-Sat 16:00-02:00

Maduro Cigar Bar on King Street off Capitol Square, the second-floor cocktail lounge and cigar room, runs classic cocktails and a hand-rolled humidor.

Signature drink: Classic cocktails with a cigar pairing

Food: Bar snacks

Gib's Bar ★ 4.6

Cocktail barSun-Mon 16:00-22:00, Tue-Thu 16:00-00:00, Fri-Sat 16:00-02:00

Gib's Bar on Williamson Street, the small craft-cocktail bar in a converted Marquette house with couches and an upstairs lounge, runs classic cocktails.

Signature drink: Old Fashioned, Negroni and classic cocktails

Food: Bar snacks

Lucille ★ 4.5

Restaurant cocktail barMon-Thu 11:00-22:00, Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00, Sun 10:00-21:00

Lucille on King Street off Capitol Square, the Underground Food Collective's wood-fire and cocktail bar, runs classic cocktails with the kitchen open late.

Signature drink: Whiskey-forward and brandy cocktails

Food: Pan-Latin pizza and shared plates

Merchant ★ 4.4

Cocktail bar and restaurantMon-Fri 11:00-23:00, Sat-Sun 10:00-23:00

Merchant on South Pinckney just off Capitol Square is the Mulligan family's downtown cocktail bar with a gastropub menu and long classic-cocktail program.

Signature drink: Craft cocktails from the Mulligan family bar

Food: American gastropub menu, charcuterie, sandwiches

See every bars pick in Madison →

← Back to Bars in Madison ← Madison food guide