For a birthday dinner in Key West, the tables we rate highest are Little Pearl (Old Town), Cafe Marquesa (Old Town) and Louie's Backyard (Casa Marina). Below, by budget and time of day: 17 places from our Key West guide, each checked against its own pages.
SeafoodOld TownMon-Sat seatings at 17:00, 19:00 and 21:00; closed Sunday
Little Pearl is a neighborhood restaurant and wine bar at 632 Olivia Street focusing on local seafood, with three dinner seatings and a custom 4 course menu.
OrderThe custom 4 course menu built on fresh local catch
TipIt is open 6 days a week and closed on Sundays, with seatings at 5:00PM, 7:00PM and 9:00PM; call the restaurant to book a table.
New AmericanOld TownBreakfast daily 08:00-11:00; dinner daily 17:00-21:00
Cafe Marquesa is the restaurant at The Marquesa Hotel on Fleming Street, serving coastal Southern cuisine with Florida Keys ingredients such as pink shrimp.
OrderThe seven-course tasting menu at $165
TipReservations are recommended, particularly for the tasting menu, which is served from 5:30 pm to 8:00 pm.
Blue Heaven is a Bahama Village restaurant at 729 Thomas Street with indoor and outdoor dining, live entertainment and Caribbean and vegetarian cuisine.
OrderA slice of the signature Key lime pie with its towering baked meringue
TipBreakfast and lunch are first come, first served and dinner has limited reservations; waiting for a table is par for the course.
Garbo's Grill is a casual Airstream food truck at Hank's Hair Of The Dog Saloon, 409 Caroline St, featured on Food Network's Diner's Drive-In's & Dive's.
OrderA tray with Korean BBQ and Umami Sliders
TipLocal and military discounts are offered, and the saloon around it is a dog friendly live music venue.
Cocktail barOld TownMon-Thu 10:00-02:00, Fri-Sat 10:00-04:00, Sun 10:00-02:00
The Green Parrot is a Key West bar and music venue at 601 Whitehead Street with no cover and no minimum, plus a gift shop by its Southard Street doors.
TipIt stays open until 4am Friday and Saturday and until 2am the rest of the week, with no cover and no minimum.
BakeryOld TownWed-Sun 07:00-12:00, subject to sellout; closed Mon-Tue
Glazed Donuts at 420 Eaton Street makes everything from scratch, with fritter-style and cake doughnuts including hibiscus syrup and candied bacon ones.
OrderThe maple bourbon and candied Canadian bacon doughnut with café con leche
TipExpect a line, as it often stretches out the door; the shop is open 7:00 am - 12:00 pm Wednesday through Sunday.
Tell the restaurant it is a birthday when you book, and ask there about cakes, candles, corkage and set menus for groups: every place has its own rules, and we list only what each one says itself. Tables at the top rooms go weeks ahead, so book early for a Friday or Saturday.