Neighborhoodst-clair-superior
HoursMon-Fri 07:00-14:30; closed Sat-Sun

Why locals love it: A 1964 sit-down deli on a non-touristy stretch of St Clair Avenue, hidden in plain sight by suburban diners not in the know

Tip: Order the corned beef on rye and ask for extra mustard; cash and card both work but the line moves faster at the counter

Location

Address: 3106 St Clair Ave NE, Cleveland, OH 44114

More hidden gems in Cleveland

Phnom Penh Restaurant ★ 4.5

ohio-cityMon-Sat 11:00-19:00; closed Sun

Phnom Penh Restaurant across from the West Side Market on West 25th Street, a family-run BYOB Cambodian room, runs the city's defining Southeast Asian noodle bowls and curries in plain sight.

Why locals love it: A family-run BYOB Cambodian room across from the West Side Market that almost nobody walking the market notices

Tip: BYOB so bring a wine across the street from the market; the coconut milk Cambodian curry is the standout

Tommy's Restaurant ★ 4.5

cleveland-heightsMon-Thu 09:00-21:00; Fri 09:00-22:00; Sat 07:30-22:00; Sun 09:00-21:00

Tommy's Restaurant on Coventry Road in Cleveland Heights since 1972, a vegetarian-leaning diner that hides a meat-eater menu, anchors the Cedar-Lee east-side diet-friendly crowd from breakfast through dinner.

Why locals love it: A 1972 vegetarian-with-meat-options diner that locals know is way better than the Coventry tourist menu suggests

Tip: Order the falafel sandwich plus a chocolate hand-mixed milkshake; the menu has every diet covered side-by-side

Velvet Tango Room ★ 4.7

tremontMon-Thu 16:30-00:00; Fri 16:30-01:00; Sat 17:00-01:00; Sun 14:00-21:00

Velvet Tango Room on Columbus Road in Tremont, Paulius Nasvytis's unmarked craft cocktail room since 1996, runs scratch-built pre-Prohibition drinks on a vintage-jazz soundtrack you have to know to find.

Why locals love it: An unmarked 1996 craft cocktail room on an industrial stretch of Columbus Road that you'd never walk past

Tip: Book ahead for a table on Friday or Saturday; every drink is built from scratch, expect a wait between rounds

Mama Santa's ★ 4.4

little-italyMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00; closed Sun

Mama Santa's on Mayfield Road in Little Italy since 1961, the Santa family Sicilian-style pizzeria, anchors the Murray Hill block's cheapest hot lunch and family-style pasta dinner side by side.

Why locals love it: A 1961 family-run Sicilian pizzeria in Little Italy that gets overshadowed by the heavier-marketed Mayfield Road pasta rooms

Tip: Order a square Sicilian pizza and a side of meatballs; the lunch slice is the cheapest hot meal in Little Italy

Astoria Cafe and Market ★ 4.5

detroit-shorewayTue-Fri 11:00-14:30, 17:00-21:00; Sat 10:00-14:30, 17:00-22:00; Sun 10:00-15:00; closed Mon

Astoria Cafe and Market on Detroit Avenue in Detroit Shoreway, a Mediterranean cafe-with-market crossing, runs shakshuka and Greek coffee alongside a tinned-fish and olive-oil retail counter at the front.

Why locals love it: A Greek-Lebanese cafe-and-market crossing on Detroit Avenue that doesn't read like a restaurant from outside

Tip: Order the shakshuka and a Greek coffee for breakfast; the front market sells olive oil and tinned fish to take home

Mitchell's Homemade Ice Cream ★ 4.6

ohio-cityMon-Thu 11:00-21:30; Fri-Sat 11:00-22:30; Sun 11:00-21:30

Mitchell's Homemade Ice Cream on West 25th Street in Ohio City, the Mitchell brothers' scoop room and production kitchen inside the former 1919 Rialto Theater, runs the city's defining daily-made ice cream.

Why locals love it: A scoop shop and production facility inside a former 1919 movie-theater entrance you can walk under without noticing

Tip: Look for the cinema marquee on West 25th; the production room is glass-walled, watch the ice cream made fresh

See every hidden gems pick in Cleveland →

← Back to Hidden Gems in Cleveland ← Cleveland food guide