6 seafood spots in Historic Seaport, editor-picked by TableJourney. All of Historic Seaport's food · All seafood in Key West.
B.O.'s Fish Wagon ★ 4.5
801 Caroline St, Key West, FL 33040
B.O.'s Fish Wagon is Key West's driftwood shack at Caroline and William, frying grouper sandwiches and cracked conch under a roof of netting and plates.
Tip: It is open-air and cash-friendly chaos; go at off-hours because the shack smells like fried fish for good reason.
Half Shell Raw Bar ★ 4.4
231 Margaret St, Key West, FL 33040
Half Shell Raw Bar shucks oysters and cures conch ceviche in a licence-plate-lined shed on Key West's Margaret Street docks, open to the harbour breeze.
Tip: Happy hour brings discounted oysters; the open-air room on the water is first-come, so aim for off-peak afternoons.
Eaton Street Seafood Market ★ 4.4
801 Eaton Street, Key West, FL 33040
Eaton Street Seafood Market sells the Key West catch two ways: over ice from the 1877 storefront case, or cooked into lobster rolls for the patio tables.
Tip: Pick a fish from the market case and they will cook it on the spot; stone crab season runs mid-October to May.
Fisherman's Cafe ★ 4.4
205 Elizabeth Street, Key West, FL 33040
Fisherman's Cafe works a small counter by Key West's Historic Seaport, stacking fish sandwiches with papaya and mango slaw for boat crews and walkers.
Tip: Seating is a few sidewalk tables on Elizabeth Street; it closes at 17:00, so treat it as a breakfast and lunch stop.
A&B Lobster House ★ 4.4
700 Front Street, Key West, FL 33040
A&B Lobster House has served surf and turf above Key West's harbour since 1947, with martinis, yacht views and the Berlin's speakeasy tucked behind it.
Tip: Ask for a balcony table over the marina; Berlin's cocktail bar behind the building serves the same A&B menu.
Conch Republic Seafood Company ★ 4.1
631 Greene Street, Key West, FL 33040
Conch Republic Seafood Company fills the old Singleton fish house on Key West's seaport with peel-and-eat pink shrimp, conch chowder and a long raw bar.
Tip: The original Singleton ice-plant floor and sign are still in place; sit at the harbour rail for the shrimp-dock view.