Restaurants in Little Italy

Mama Santa's ★ 4.4

Italian$$little-italyMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00; closed Sun

Mama Santa's on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, the family-owned Sicilian pizzeria since 1961, runs hand-tossed pies and homemade pasta on the Italian block.

Signature: Sicilian pizza, Handmade manicotti

Order: Sicilian sausage pizza and a plate of the manicotti to share.

Tip: Takes reservations and walk-ins; the patio opens in warm months. Closed Sunday.

Trattoria on the Hill ★ 4.2

Italian$$$little-italyMon 11:30-20:30; Tue-Thu 11:30-21:00; Fri-Sat 11:30-22:00; Sun 11:30-20:30

Trattoria on the Hill on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, an Italian-American dining room since 1988, runs hearty traditional pasta plates and veal mains.

Signature: Homemade pasta, Veal piccata

Order: Eggplant parmesan and the chicken piccata, plus a slice of cassata cake to finish.

Tip: Reserves through Tock; the patio opens in warm months and Little Italy parking is tight outside the lot.

Casual Dining in Little Italy

Mama Santa's ★ 4.6

Italian$$little-italyMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00; closed Sun

Mama Santa's on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, the family-owned Sicilian pizzeria since 1961, runs hand-tossed pies and homemade pasta on the Italian block.

Signature: Sicilian pizza, Homemade manicotti

Order: Sicilian sausage pizza and a plate of the manicotti to share.

Tip: Takes reservations and walk-ins; the patio opens in warm months. Closed Sunday.

Trattoria on the Hill ★ 4.3

Italian$$$little-italyMon 11:30-20:30; Tue-Thu 11:30-21:00; Fri-Sat 11:30-22:00; Sun 11:30-20:30

Trattoria on the Hill on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, an Italian-American dining room since 1988, runs hearty traditional pasta plates and veal mains.

Signature: Eggplant parmesan, Chicken piccata

Order: Eggplant parmesan and chicken piccata, plus a slice of cassata cake to finish.

Tip: First-come, first-served seating most nights. Little Italy parking is tight outside the lot.

Bakeries in Little Italy

Presti's Bakery ★ 4.7

Bakery$little-italyMon-Fri 06:00-19:00, Sat 06:00-18:00, Sun 07:00-15:00Walk-in onlyItalian-American pastries and breads

Presti's Bakery on Mayfield Road in Little Italy since 1903, one of Cleveland's oldest bakeries, anchors the Cleveland-style cassata cake tradition.

Worth the queue: Cassata cake

Corbo's Bakery ★ 4.6

Bakery$little-italyDaily 08:00-19:00Walk-in onlyItalian-American pastries

Corbo's Bakery on Mayfield Road in Little Italy since 1958, the family-owned bakery known for cassata cake and cannoli, has expanded to a full Italian menu.

Worth the queue: Cassata cake

Food Tours in Little Italy

★ 4.5

little-italy

Taste Cleveland Little Italy Food Tour, the three-hour walking tour through Mayfield Road Italian bakeries, pasta rooms and the Cleveland-style cassata cake.

Food Festivals in Little Italy

Feast of the Assumption ★ 4.8

little-italy

Feast of the Assumption on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, the four-day Holy Rosary church festival since 1898 honoring the Assumption of Mary.

Budget Eats in Little Italy

Mama Santa's ★ 4.4

Sicilian$little-italyMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00; closed Sun

Mama Santa's on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, the Sicilian-style pizzeria run by the Santa family since 1961, anchors the cheap lunch slice scene.

Try: Square Sicilian pizza slice and a side of meatballs

Hidden Gems in Little Italy

Mama Santa's ★ 4.0

Sicilian$$little-italyMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00; closed Sun

Mama Santa's on Mayfield Road in Little Italy since 1961 is the Santa family Sicilian pizzeria with the block's cheapest hot lunch and family pasta dinners.

Why locals love it: A 1961 family-run Sicilian pizzeria in Little Italy that gets overshadowed by the heavier-marketed Mayfield Road pasta rooms

Tip: Order a square Sicilian pizza and a side of meatballs; the lunch slice is the cheapest hot meal in Little Italy

← Back to the Cleveland food guide

Cuisines in Little Italy