Restaurants in Little Italy

Mama Santa's ★ 4.5

Italian$$little-italyMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00; closed Sun

Mama Santa's on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, the family-owned Sicilian pizzeria since 1961, anchors the Italian-American block with hand-tossed pies and homemade pasta.

Signature: Sicilian pizza, Handmade manicotti

Order: Sicilian sausage pizza and a plate of the manicotti to share.

Tip: Takes reservations and walk-ins; the patio opens in warm months. Closed Sunday.

Trattoria on the Hill ★ 4.4

Italian$$$little-italyMon 11:30-20:30; Tue-Thu 11:30-21:00; Fri-Sat 11:30-22:00; Sun 11:30-20:30

Trattoria on the Hill on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, an Italian-American dining room since 1988, runs hearty traditional pasta plates and veal mains.

Signature: Homemade pasta, Veal piccata

Order: Eggplant parmesan and the chicken piccata, plus a slice of cassata cake to finish.

Tip: Reserves through Tock; the patio opens in warm months and Little Italy parking is tight outside the lot.

Casual Dining in Little Italy

Mama Santa's ★ 4.5

Italian$$little-italyMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00; closed Sun

Mama Santa's on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, the family-owned Sicilian pizzeria since 1961, anchors the Italian-American block with hand-tossed pies and homemade pasta dishes.

Signature: Sicilian pizza, Homemade manicotti

Order: Sicilian sausage pizza and a plate of the manicotti to share.

Tip: Takes reservations and walk-ins; the patio opens in warm months. Closed Sunday.

Trattoria on the Hill ★ 4.4

Italian$$$little-italyMon 11:30-20:30; Tue-Thu 11:30-21:00; Fri-Sat 11:30-22:00; Sun 11:30-20:30

Trattoria on the Hill on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, an Italian-American dining room since 1988, runs hearty traditional pasta plates and veal mains with a parking lot.

Signature: Eggplant parmesan, Chicken piccata

Order: Eggplant parmesan and chicken piccata, plus a slice of cassata cake to finish.

Tip: First-come, first-served seating most nights. Little Italy parking is tight outside the lot.

Bakeries in Little Italy

Presti's Bakery ★ 4.7

little-italyMon-Fri 06:00-19:00, Sat 06:00-18:00, Sun 07:00-15:00Walk-in onlyItalian-American pastries and breads

Presti's Bakery on Mayfield Road in Little Italy since 1903, one of Cleveland's oldest bakeries, anchors the Cleveland-style cassata cake tradition.

Worth the queue: Cassata cake

Corbo's Bakery ★ 4.6

little-italyDaily 08:00-19:00Walk-in onlyItalian-American pastries

Corbo's Bakery on Mayfield Road in Little Italy since 1958, the family-owned bakery known for cassata cake and cannoli, has expanded to a full Italian menu.

Worth the queue: Cassata cake

Food Tours in Little Italy

★ 4.5

little-italy

Taste Cleveland Little Italy Food Tour, the three-hour walking tour through Mayfield Road Italian bakeries, pasta rooms and the Cleveland-style cassata cake tradition, samples at multiple Murray Hill stops.

Food Festivals in Little Italy

Feast of the Assumption ★ 4.7

little-italy

Feast of the Assumption on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, the four-day Holy Rosary church festival since 1898 honoring the Assumption of Mary, runs a Saturday procession plus Italian street food and pasta.

Budget Eats in Little Italy

Mama Santa's ★ 4.4

little-italyMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00; closed Sun

Mama Santa's on Mayfield Road in Little Italy, the Sicilian-style pizzeria run by the Santa family since 1961, anchors the cheap-lunch slice scene on the Murray Hill block.

Try: Square Sicilian pizza slice and a side of meatballs

Hidden Gems in Little Italy

Mama Santa's ★ 4.4

little-italyMon-Thu 11:00-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:00-23:00; closed Sun

Mama Santa's on Mayfield Road in Little Italy since 1961, the Santa family Sicilian-style pizzeria, anchors the Murray Hill block's cheapest hot lunch and family-style pasta dinner side by side.

Why locals love it: A 1961 family-run Sicilian pizzeria in Little Italy that gets overshadowed by the heavier-marketed Mayfield Road pasta rooms

Tip: Order a square Sicilian pizza and a side of meatballs; the lunch slice is the cheapest hot meal in Little Italy

← Back to the Cleveland food guide

Cuisines in Little Italy